Testsystems
All articles

Know-how

Magnetic field measurement vs. back EMF test

Back EMF analysis is one of the most established methods for testing electric motors. It gives a good picture of whether the motor works properly, but it also has weak spots, as this article explains.

In back EMF measurement, the rotor is driven from outside at a set speed. The winding terminals are left open. As the rotor turns, its field induces a voltage in the motor’s windings. This voltage is the back electromotive force (back EMF). From the amplitude, waveform and symmetry of the back EMF in the three phases, you can judge whether the magnets and windings are in order.

The drawback of the method is that it only tests the fully assembled motor. If faults in the magnetic field are found at that point, the motor may in the worst case have to be taken apart again. On top of the assembly effort, this often scraps magnets and bearings.

The method also has a built-in limit: not every magnet fault shows in the back EMF as it is usually evaluated in practice. To put the method to the test, a customer’s test team deliberately removed single magnets from an 8-pole PSM rotor. The missing magnets went unnoticed in the back EMF measurement, because their effect on the amplitude was spread across all poles. Only when several magnets were missing did the fault begin to show in the measurement. In vehicle operation, such magnetic asymmetries lead over time to audible noise and one-sided bearing load.

Magnetic field measurement
On the rotor alone, before assembly
Magnetic field measurement: On the rotor alone, before assembly NSNSNNS Sensor Rotation Missing magnet
Field across one revolution, one magnet missing
The missing magnet shows at its own pole.
Back EMF measurement
On the assembled motor, driven at a set speed
Back EMF measurement: On the assembled motor, driven at a set speed Drive Assembled motor Voltage measurement U V W
Voltage of phases U, V and W, same rotor
The loss spreads across all poles, so the curves look normal.

It therefore makes sense to check the quality of the rotor field before assembly. Our test benches analyze the magnetic field pole by pole and also reveal deviations that a back EMF measurement later does not reliably show.

The two methods complement each other well: magnetic field testing narrows the fault analysis down to the rotor, while back EMF analysis examines how rotor and windings work together after assembly.

At a glance:

Magnetic field measurementBack EMF measurement
When it testsBefore assembly, on the rotor aloneAfter assembly, on the finished motor
What it testsThe rotor’s magnetic fieldThe voltage the rotor induces in the windings
ResolutionEvery pole on its own; a deviation can be traced to its poleOne summed signal per phase across all poles
Key figuresPeak, polarity, width and center of every pole, pole symmetry, FFTAmplitude, waveform and symmetry of the three phases
One missing magnetShows at the affected poleSpreads across all poles and can go unnoticed in the usual evaluation
When a fault is foundThe rotor is sorted out before it is built inIn the worst case the motor has to be taken apart, and magnets and bearings are scrapped
WindingsNot part of the testTested as well

Would you like to know more?